Weekly News via Email
   Set as homepage | Add to favorites | Customer Service | Subscribe Now | Place an Ad | Contact Us | Sitemap Saturday, 02.17.2018
News Archive
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
 2  3  4  5  6  7  8
 9  10  11  12  13  14  15
 16  17  18  19  20  21  22
 23  24  25  26  27  28  29
 30  31
Online Extras
Site Services
Around Bend
Outdoor Fun
Travel Info
Shop Local

Members Of

Poll: Today's Live Poll
Email to a friend | Print this | PDF version | Comments (0 posted) 
  Blogger |   del.icio.us |   digg |   newsvine

Mar 28,2008
Chief justice sends the president a message
by The San Diego Union-Tribune

There were many legal cross-currents involved in the U.S. Supreme Court's decision this week to side with Texas against the Bush administration and the International Court of Justice in a case involving a Mexican national on death row. Jose Medellin was not allowed to consult with diplomats from his home country after his arrest in a 1993 murder-rape investigation, in violation of the Vienna Convention - an international treaty dealing with the treatment of foreigners facing serious criminal allegations. The ICJ ruled that Medellin and 50 other Texas prisoners who faced similar circumstances should be given new hearings to determine if the state's failure to notify Mexico violated the prisoners' right to a fair trial.

But Texas courts noted that Medellin had already exhausted his appeal rights and held the international treaty did not have the force of law in their state because its provisions had never been formally enacted by Congress. This prompted President George W. Bush to issue an unprecedented 2005 memo ordering Texas to hold the hearings. The Texas courts held firm, leaving it up to the federal courts to resolve.

Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. confronted this complex case - with its conflicting theories about separation of powers, state vs. federal authority and the scope of international treaties - and fashioned a compelling decision that made two crucial points. The first is that international courts do not have binding power in American legal disputes unless such power is specifically enumerated in federal law. The second is that a president cannot order a state to do anything unless his authority to do so is specifically enumerated in federal law or the Constitution.

We believe the unusual circumstances - and the fact that Americans abroad deserve the protections that were denied the 51 Mexicans in Texas - should have led Texas officials to voluntarily decide to hold hearings. But their decision not to do so is hardly a mistake of such gravity that it should trump the fundamental notion that America is governed by laws, not presidential fiats.

Given all this White House has done to expand executive power, Roberts' decision - especially his observation that there are many actions a president cannot undertake without specific authorization from Congress - often reads like a larger commentary on the Bush administration's baroque legal theories. The chief justice's opinion could be a harbinger of how the high court would rule on the White House's breathtaking claim that the president can use "signing statements" to unilaterally redefine the scope of newly enacted legislation.

If it is a harbinger, that is great news. Many legal experts have asserted Roberts was chosen for the Supreme Court because of what they presumed was his expansive view of presidential powers. The Medellin case, however, shows he understands, appreciates and plans to protect the checks and balances that have served this nation so well for so long.

In other words, the chief justice has given admirers of the Constitution cause to celebrate.

Reprinted from The San Diego Union-Tribune - CNS.

1068 times read

Related news
Law of the Sea Treaty would swamp U.S. legal system by Phyllis_Schlafly posted on Oct 26,2007

A new term by The San Diego Union-Tribune posted on Oct 05,2007

Absurd claim reflects Bush's recklessness by The San Diego Union-Tribune posted on Jun 29,2007

Supreme Court ruling could have broad impact by Paul M. Krawzak posted on Feb 21,2007

Gonzales lessons by The San Diego Union-Tribune posted on Aug 31,2007

Did you enjoy this article? Rating: 5.00Rating: 5.00Rating: 5.00Rating: 5.00Rating: 5.00 (total 36 votes)

Market Information
Breaking News
Most Popular
Most Commented
Featured Columnist
Horoscope Guide
Aquarius Aquarius Libra Libra
Aries Aries Pisces Pisces
Cancer Cancer Sagittarius Sagittarius
Capricorn Capricorn Scorpio Scorpio
Gemini Gemini Taurus Taurus
Leo Leo Virgo Virgo
Local Attractions
Bend Visitors & Convention Bureau
Bend Visitors & Convention Bureau

Mt. Bachelor Resort
Mt. Bachelor Resort

Les Schwab Ampitheater
Les Schwab Ampitheater

Deschutes County Fairgrounds
Deschutes County

Tower Theatre
Tower Theatre

The High Desert Museum


Deschutes County

  Web    BendWeekly.com
© 2006 Bend Weekly News
A .Com Endeavors, Inc. Company.
All Rights Reserved. Terms under
which this service is provided to you.
Please read our Privacy Policy. Contact us.
Bend Weekly News & Event Guide Online
   Save the Net
External sites open in new window,
not endorsed by BendWeekly.com
Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Add to Google Add to MSN Add to My AOL
What are RSS headlines?